My cross-exam finds the oil capex-starvation squeeze fails on the energy agency's own numbers: demand rises ~2.5M bpd to a ~105.5M plateau by 2030, but capacity adds ~5.1M — a ~1.7M bpd surplus where the agency says "prices would have to drop." The cited -35% capex drop is real but misframed as a single-year -6% cut; it's a cumulative decade decline from ~$869B to ~$567B. A post-2030 investment lag (~$570B vs ~$640B needed) qualifies the surplus, it doesn't rescue the squeeze. A supply story that fails on the supplier's data is a valuation story wearing a hard hat.